Research into the Source of modern bellydance

topic posted Thu, October 6, 2005 - 10:43 AM by  Lindy Lou
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Hi Everyone,

I am passionate about bellydance but I don't feel like I know enough about its origins and leaders in the development of the dance to now.

I am the type of girl who needs to know where I am coming from in order to know where I am going :)

Where should I begin to look for understanding the dance from the inside out? Where and who do I start with? Who are the main "teachers" from the original dance and sources in the Middle East? Why are they so important? Are there books? Are there documentaries?

Any help is so appreciated and thanks so much!!!
posted by:
Lindy Lou
Canada
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

    Wed, October 19, 2005 - 2:29 PM
    Talk to Shareen el Safy and Sahra Kent if you're interested in how modern Egyptian bellydance grew out of the social dance/folkloric forms.

    (Shareen was a student of Jamila's way back when.)

    I'd take every page of Serpent and the Nile with a HUGE grain of salt. Wendy has a very obvious axe to grind, and it shows in this book.
    • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

      Fri, October 21, 2005 - 2:00 PM
      aloha everyone. now take this with a grain of sand, cause i don't know where he got his sources from. but this is so worth reading, especially if you love dance and it gives you that tingly feeling that it is so much more than just you... ...

      "Skinny Legs and All" by Tom Robbins, does an excellent (and somewhat steamy and scandalous) job of describing pre-Abraham life and dance in the Land of Canaan. it's a fabulous histori-fiction tale and particularly relevant in these times.

      and a must have for everyone in the universe:
      "The Women's Encyclopedia of Myths and Secrets" by Barbara Walker (not Walters!)
  • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

    Fri, November 4, 2005 - 9:43 AM
    Darling, the best place to look is your heart! Not everything done by our pioneering dancers comforts everyone's taste, and I find that through watching videos of everyone I possibly can from the 60's, 70's, 80's, 90's and 00's I develop and grow certain ideas of my own and understand how the story unfolds in a feeling way. The stories that our sisters have told has been written about enough, and still the best place to learn is visually!!! Through the expressions in these women's faces, a million stories are told that you'll never find explained in books. The truest emotions of the lives they lived and their dreams and aspirations are all there!
    • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

      Fri, November 4, 2005 - 10:19 AM
      'Tis true...I need to find some money for DVD's. Is there a good place to get ones of dancers from the 60's, 70's etc?

      And you are right...watching IS learning and moving is living :)
      • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

        Fri, November 4, 2005 - 2:31 PM
        SWEETIE YOU'RE IN CANADA AND I AM IN LONDON! If you came here I'd point you in the right direction down Edgeware Rd, but I dont know where to recommend, save the internet. I have seen videos on ebay sometimes, and am certain that there are more sites out there. In London we often have big Souk's at festivals and then we all go out shopping and pick up what we need. I could recommend some UK companies who are on the internet. Aladdins Cave are really good stockists for CDs and video. But Im sure youve got a local supply that would be cheaper. Happy hunting honey! Theyre out there xx
      • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

        Sun, November 20, 2005 - 1:43 PM
        I've not see a lot of dancer footage from the 60's and 70's. The Legends of Bellydance DVD has some for dancers in Egypt and nearby, and there's a few videos of dancers from that time period who were here; the Hizz ya Wiz video, to hit the best one that I have, covers the early years of the Aswan Dance Troupe in San Francisco. Keep in mind that most of this stuff will _not_ be on DVD; you're frankly lucky to get 'em on VHS.

        I'd recommend Dahlal International, Scheherezade Imports, Audrena's, or Artemis Imports as good "old school" vendors, who you can contact and ask about these kind of videos. Look 'em up on Google for contact information.

        Does that help? :)
  • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

    Mon, January 1, 2007 - 4:31 PM
    I would go directly to the source. If you subscribe to DISH network, then subscribe to the Arabic channels. One can learn much about Egyptian dance and culture just by watching Egyptian movies....ALL of them, not just necessarily the ones that feature dance. About two-thirds of these movies are all subtitled in English. The Egyptian movies are our first teachers.

    -Sausan
  • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

    Mon, January 1, 2007 - 8:18 PM
    An excellent book to read is A Trade Like Any Other by Karin van Nieuwkerk. (which I have probably misspelled). It's not easy to read - it's her PhD dissertation and is written in rather academic language. But it's a superb resource for learning how our dance form evolved from its roots as a social dance into a performing art.

    Another good resource is Looking for Little Egypt, by Donna Carlton. That one provides insights into how the general U.S. public became aware of "belly dance" at the end of the 19th century and early 20th century.

    The DVD Legends of Belly Dance provides a good introduction to what the famous dancers of Egypt were like in the 1940's and later.

    I know someone else on this thread suggested Serpent of the Nile by Wendy Buonaventura. I actually don't recommend that one, because it contains a lot of "wishtory" and is very weak when it comes to identifying its sources.

    Someone else suggested The Belly Dance Book - and I agree that its history section is excellent.

    I hope this helps!
    • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

      Tue, January 2, 2007 - 4:08 PM
      To Shira's wise port, I would also add:

      ""An hour for God and an hour for the heart": Islam, gender and female entertainment in Egypt at:
      research.umbc.edu/eol/MA/in...arin_0.htm -- this is van Nieuwkerk's followup piece to A TRADE LIKE ANY OTHER, and I generally recommend it as excellent background to the cultural implications of raqs shaqri and related forms in modern Egypt. Since it's online and fairly short, it's not a burden to get to, although it is written in the same academic tongue as TRADE.

      Belly Dance: Orientalism, Transnationalism, And Harem Fantasy -- possibly the best single book available in English for Raqs Shaqri research, in my opinion. It's an excellent work on just about every aspect of the dance; there are weaknesses, including the piece on American Tribal, and, orignically enough, I wanted much more of the actual origins, although it does a great job of giving you media context (like with the movies Su mentioned) within the culture, as well as the myriad of other aspects to this dance form.
      • Re: Research into the Source of modern bellydance

        Wed, January 3, 2007 - 10:15 PM
        You don't like "Body, Image, Identity", Woodrow? I think it's *awesome*, one of the most academically useful pieces in the book in terms of looking at *why* western women belly dance and what they get out of it. It's got much wider application than tribal though.

        I love the "An Evening in the Orient" article - that is very useful for anyone who wants to learn more about the background of ME dance in America's clublands. But yes, the whole book is worth its price, which is pretty low considering.

Recent topics in "Belly Dance Legacy"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Ozel Turkbas on Youtube Unsubscribed 17 December 13, 2009
Belly dance in the 70's compared to now Noraia 43 December 7, 2009
A Word on Sword Dancing bellydancing... 5 November 29, 2009
Jihan, Vintage Detroit Belly Dancer, Folkloric Show, 1980's Norma 0 November 1, 2009